How the NYC mayor's race turned into a political ‘Freaky Friday’

This column originally appeared in The Politics Brief, our weekly newsletter on the people, power and policies that shape New Yorkers' lives.

Sign up to get the full version where you can ask questions, share news tips and weigh in on the conversation. Hits inboxes on Wednesdays.

There has been no honeymoon for Zohran Mamdani since the front-runner in New York City's mayoral race returned to the campaign trail after his wedding celebration in Uganda last month.

Even before his return flight landed at JFK Airport, Mamdani faced a weeklong interrogation of his public safety policies following a mass shooting. Mamdani’s most viable challenger, former Gov. Andrew Cuomo, followed that with a provocative debate over whether the assemblymember from Queens should be allowed to live in his $2,300-a-month rent-stabilized apartment.

Has the script flipped for the general election?

Cuomo, who ran a disastrous Rose Garden strategy in the Democratic primary, now looks like the aggressive underdog. Mamdani, meanwhile, has spent the last several weeks fending off rivals’ attacks on his policies and personal life.

“It feels like Freaky Friday,” said Trip Yang, Democratic strategist, alluding to the body-swapping hit movie that just got a sequel. “In the primary, Cuomo was this juggernaut. Zohran was this viral sensation.”

“The roles are reversed,” he added.

Sal Albanese, a former city councilmember and mayoral candidate who supports Mamdani, agreed.

“The campaign is playing defense,” he said. “I don’t think that’s good going into the fall.”

The shift comes as Mamdani adapts to the role of front-runner while seeking the support of establishment Democrats and business leaders. That effort has coincided with his hiring of several veteran political insiders.

For most of the primary, the 33-year-old democratic socialist ran as a long-shot candidate who seemed to have nothing to lose. On Tuesday, a Siena College poll showed him leading a five-person field with 44% support from registered voters.

Cuomo, who is running as an independent, is in second place with 25%. The 67-year-old former governor has recast himself on social media as a snarky and at times unhinged mayoral candidate.

“In case you forgot, I’m Andrew Cuomo, son of Mario, grandson of Andrea,” Cuomo said on X on Friday, in a kind of medieval proclamation about his royal lineage.“Welcome to the heavyweight bout @ZohranKMamdani This is a two man race. You look tired already. It’s just the second round.”

Mamdani has defended changes to his campaign. “I'm not looking to just be the mayor for the more than 500,000 New Yorkers who voted for me in the primary,” he said during a press conference in Brooklyn on Tuesday. “I'm looking to be the mayor for New Yorkers who voted for Andrew Cuomo, for New Yorkers who didn't vote at all.”

Mamdani described his new campaign team as one that would “ensure that we can continue to grow our message and our presence across the entirety of the city.”

As Cuomo nips at his heels, Mamdani has launched a five-borough tour highlighting the effects of President Donald Trump’s policies. Also, on Tuesday afternoon, Mamdani released an attack ad, demanding Cuomo release the list of clients he advised as a consultant after resigning from office.

Cuomo, seemingly unruffled, responded with a meme.

Listen here

We want to hear from you

Andrew Cuomo has become more aggressive as an independent candidate for mayor. Do you like it?

We'll share responses in next week's newsletter. (Sign up!)

This week in New York politics

• A former aide to Mayor Eric Adams pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud in a Manhattan federal courtroom on Tuesday. Here are the details.
• Should New York state troopers get paid leave after ‘critical incidents?’ It could happen under this bill.
• President Trump took over the D.C. police department and hinted at doing the same in NYC. But legal experts say it would be much harder. Here’s why.
• The NYPD currently handles mental health calls in the city. But could Zohran Mamdani change that? Here’s what experts say.
• Gov. Kathy Hochul said the Republican-led redistricting in Texas is a “legal insurrection” and a “blatant power grab” during a recent Fox News appearance. Here’s what else she said.
• Federal prosecutors have issued subpoenas to Attorney General Letitia James related to two of her most controversial cases. Here’s why.
• Listen: WNYC/Gothamist reporter Arun Venugopal came on ”The Brian Lehrer Show” to share his reporting on how NYC’s tourism industry is suffering because of President Trump's tariffs and other policies. Listen here.